Image Credit: Compass
Michelle Williams owns a striking 6,480-square-foot Colonial Revival mansion in Brooklyn’s historic Prospect Park South.
Dubbed the “Tara of Prospect Park South,” the estate evokes the iconic Gone With the Wind mansion with its dramatic, two-story columned porch.
Originally built in 1910 by architects Robert Bryson and Carroll Pratt, the residence sits on a corner parcel just two blocks from Prospect Park.
The landmarked neighborhood, developed in the early 20th century, is celebrated for its freestanding homes and rich architectural legacy.
Williams’ home stands out among the 206 residences in the district for its exceptional scale and design.
Interior Features and Restoration
Restored by Matiz Architecture and Workstead Design, the home preserves its original charm while embracing modern luxury. The grand foyer features a sweeping staircase and original fireplace, leading into a formal living room adorned with a bay window and wood-burning fireplace.
A formal dining room includes a built-in window seat, while the library boasts floor-to-ceiling bookshelves.
The eat-in kitchen, equipped with radiant-heat flooring, marble countertops, and a six-burner La Cornue range, opens to the backyard.
Upstairs, the primary suite offers a dressing room, home office, decorative mantel, and an en suite bath complete with a clawfoot tub, sauna, and private deck.
Layout and Living Spaces
The mansion includes eight bedrooms, six full bathrooms, and three half-bathrooms across three floors.
On the second level, three additional bedrooms have their own en suite baths, and a library connects to a covered porch.
The third floor holds three more bedrooms, a full bath, and a gym with a massage table and Peloton treadmill.
A one-bedroom apartment, studio, gym area, and additional storage occupy the cellar, which also connects to the parlor level.
Each level balances privacy with generous communal space, creating a functional layout suited to both family life and entertaining.
Outdoor Amenities and Security
A heated saltwater lap pool sits amid wraparound landscaping and brick pathways, creating a serene urban retreat.
The backyard also features a charming fountain and private two-car garage—a rare amenity in New York City.
Additional outdoor areas include multiple covered porches and expansive decks that provide ideal spots for relaxing or hosting.
A wireless alarm system and neighborhood security ensure peace of mind.
Automatic irrigation and central air conditioning enhance the home’s convenience and comfort.
Michelle Williams’ Real Estate Ventures
Williams has demonstrated a keen sense for real estate, having previously owned a townhouse in Boerum Hill that reportedly sold for well above its asking price.
In 2020, she and her husband, Hamilton director Thomas Kail, purchased a townhouse in Brooklyn Heights for $10.8 million. Her properties reflect both historical significance and contemporary sophistication.
The Prospect Park South mansion, which she purchased for $2.5 million in 2015, represents one of her most impressive holdings.
She currently rents the estate for $35,000 per month.
Personal and Professional Background
Raised in Montana, Williams first gained attention through her role on Dawson’s Creek before achieving critical acclaim in Brokeback Mountain.
Her performance earned her an Academy Award nomination and introduced her to co-star Heath Ledger, with whom she shares a daughter, Matilda.
Williams has since received multiple Oscar nominations for her roles in films like Blue Valentine, Manchester by the Sea, and The Fabelmans.
She met Kail on the set of Fosse/Verdon, and the couple married in 2020.
Their shared life in Brooklyn blends professional success with a deep appreciation for timeless architecture.
More Photos of the Home
The Colonial Revival mansion’s entrance features towering columns, a sweeping staircase, and a covered porch, highlighting its timeless beauty and grand scale in Prospect Park South.
Image Credit: Compass
A peaceful garden surrounds the elegant stone fountain, offering a serene retreat amidst lush greenery, beautifully complementing the historic charm of the home’s outdoor spaces, perfect for relaxation and reflection.
Image Credit: Compass
This brick-lined pathway winds through meticulously landscaped gardens, leading to quiet seating areas and the stunning outdoor fountain, providing an inviting, private outdoor oasis for this luxurious Brooklyn estate.
Image Credit: Compass
The expansive heated saltwater pool, surrounded by a brick patio and mature trees, offers a luxurious outdoor feature, creating a perfect setting for leisurely swims in the comfort of this urban oasis.
Image Credit: Compass
A beautifully designed upper porch, framed by grand columns, overlooks the lush surroundings of the property, offering a tranquil space to enjoy the peaceful ambiance of the historic Prospect Park South neighborhood.
Image Credit: Compass
The grand entryway boasts a sweeping staircase, intricate crown molding, and a round table centerpiece, creating an inviting and sophisticated introduction to this beautifully restored Colonial Revival mansion.
Image Credit: Compass
A classic spiral staircase, accented with black-and-white steps and wainscoting, leads gracefully to the upper floors, serving as a striking architectural focal point of the home.
Image Credit: Compass
The curved railing on the upper landing showcases expert craftsmanship, offering a seamless flow between levels while adding a touch of refined elegance to the home’s design.
Image Credit: Compass
Stained glass windows frame the hallway, offering an artistic touch to the home’s architecture, while the beautifully finished wood floors add warmth to this transitional space.
Image Credit: Compass
The charming library features floor-to-ceiling bookshelves, a cozy window seat, and a vibrant floral couch, creating the perfect space to enjoy a good book or reflect quietly.
Image Credit: Compass
This stylish living room highlights a decorative fireplace, artistic green wallpaper, and comfortable seating, blending historic charm with modern design for relaxed and sophisticated entertaining.
Image Credit: Compass
A vibrant living room showcases green striped walls, floral wallpaper, and cozy grey sofas, all centered around a unique coffee table, under a modern chandelier, and framed by a large bay window overlooking lush gardens.
Image Credit: Compass
A light-filled dining area connects seamlessly with the living space, offering an inviting setting for meals or gatherings, surrounded by intricate architectural details and a wall of windows.
Image Credit: Compass
This curved bay window in the breakfast nook features beautiful stained-glass details, offering a sunny spot to enjoy meals while overlooking the lush gardens outside.
Image Credit: Compass
The study exudes warmth with plush seating, expansive bookshelves, and large windows, creating a peaceful retreat for reading or working in comfort and style.
Image Credit: Compass
This cozy sitting room features a playful combination of colorful artwork, comfortable seating, and large windows, creating an inviting space to relax while surrounded by curated décor and views of the outdoors.
Image Credit: Compass
A hidden nook beneath the staircase offers a cozy reading spot, complete with rich wood paneling and a vintage chair, adding character and charm to this architectural detail.
Image Credit: Compass
The breakfast nook, framed by expansive windows and terracotta tile floors, offers a serene space to enjoy meals while looking out onto the beautifully landscaped gardens surrounding the property.
Image Credit: Compass
Designed for both function and style, the gourmet kitchen includes a spacious marble island, top-tier appliances, and terracotta tile floors ideal for casual gatherings.
Image Credit: Compass 
Image Credit: Compass
The combination of wooden cabinetry, marble countertops, and modern lighting in this kitchen blends traditional charm with contemporary style, creating a functional and aesthetically pleasing culinary space.
Image Credit: Compass
Filled with comfort and sophistication, the spacious primary bedroom features soft green walls, a large bed, and a plush seating area that creates a serene retreat.
Image Credit: Compass
The primary bedroom features a comfortable bed, fireplace, and large windows, with soft textures and subtle greenery creating a peaceful and luxurious atmosphere for relaxation.
Image Credit: Compass
A vibrant guest bedroom showcases a fun mix of eclectic art, a hanging chair, and colorful accents, providing an energetic yet cozy space for guests to unwind and feel at home.
Image Credit: Compass
An open suite combines relaxation and entertainment with a television area, a shuffleboard table, and bay windows framing views of the lush greenery outside, making it perfect for leisure.
Image Credit: Compass
This airy loft bedroom boasts unique architectural details and access to a private balcony, offering a bright and inviting space for relaxation and restful nights.
Image Credit: Compass
The beautifully detailed powder room features floral wallpaper, a classic basin, and brass fixtures, combining timeless design elements with a touch of elegance and charm.
Image Credit: Compass
A spacious bathroom, complete with a claw-foot tub, dual pedestal sinks, and gold accents, creates a luxurious retreat perfect for unwinding after a long day.
Image Credit: Compass
This stunning bathroom offers dual pedestal sinks, a spacious shower, and gold accents throughout, providing a blend of functionality and sophistication for a refreshing start to any day.
Image Credit: Compass
A bright, modern bathroom showcases vibrant floral wallpaper and a glass-enclosed shower, creating a cheerful and fresh environment for daily routines.
Image Credit: Compass
The striking marbled wallpaper complements the classic clawfoot tub in this luxurious bathroom, where modern fixtures meet vintage design in an unexpected and stylish combination.
Image Credit: Compass
A whimsical guest bathroom features playful aquatic-themed wallpaper, brass accents, and clean white tiles, offering a fun and refreshing space for guests.
Image Credit: Compass
This beautifully crafted sauna features warm wood paneling, offering a private and relaxing space to unwind and rejuvenate after a long day.
Image Credit: Compass